Some Warhammer Bashing from the Telegraph.co.uk

The Telegraph

Dr Timothy Stanley is a British scholar of United States politics. He is also a blogger for The Telegraph and he really doesn’t like the Warhammer hobby much (at least, not anymore).


#1 – Should David Cameron Ban Warhammer?

There’s the odd quirky article about Warhammer every few months or so in the “main stream” news. Most recently (as far as I am aware), BBC had a go at Games Workshop during the debate surrounding Spots the Space Marine (and whether GW can claim the term “Space Marine”).

Dr Stanely, however, is less concerned with Games Workshop as a company, and more with his own (in retrospect unpleasant) experiences collecting a Warhammer Fantasy army or two.

If David Cameron must ban anything, let it be Warhammer fantasy games.

 I started small – a few skirmishes in the changing rooms, an armed confrontation in the library – and soon worked my way up to a massive army of faux-French knights called Bretonnians. I got the painting bug and by age 15 I was getting through 10, maybe 20 archers a week. We’re talking two coats and a bucketful of superglue. Most evenings I was as high as a kite. 

His argument, in a nutshell, seems to be that wargaming is both addictive and inherently uncool (e.g. you can’t possibly have a collection of miniatures, Black Library novels AND a social life… widely known as the fourth law of thermodynamics).

What got me off the habit? Girls. In my first week at university I visited the room of another collector and his shelves were covered in Space Marines. I thought, “Dude, you’re not going to get any action at all.” So I threw away my Bretonnian army and tried to put my past behind me.

Even though Dr Stanely miraculously recovered, he evidently fears that most young boys do not have the iron will he displayed in kicking his glue-sniffing miniature-painting habits.

The reasonable solution, evidently, would thus be for the government to intervene and ban the lot.

But the war on collecting camp little miniatures is one worth fighting, Mr Cameron. If only to save the next generation of boys from the years of acne and sexual deprivation that inevitably follow.

Wargaming-abstinence prevents acne?


#2 – Thoughts?

Admittedly, the article tries for a light-hearted approach. The plea for the Prime Minister to ban the hobby is the (presumably) tongue-in-cheek conclusion to this article.

Still, the article is oozing with contempt for the Warhammer hobby, and the (very original) assertion that wargaming hobbyists are, without exception, hopelessly a-social boys and men (no women though…. Dr Stanely probably isn’t subscribed Joeyberry et. al.) seems genuine.

It’s a pity Tim Stanely had to go through a few rough patches during his youth and later studies (I am certain that without Warhammer miniatures it would’ve been smooth sailing all the way).

Than again, if he feels the need to blame the plastic toys, and not so much himself, for his periods of procrastination, Dr Stanely perhaps hasn’t yet truly overcome his issues, as he clearly thinks he has, simply by dumping some Bretonnians.

Z.

About Zweischneid

Hi. I am Zweischneid. Wargame Addict. Miniature Connoisseur. Aspiring Blogger. Did you like this post? Follow me on Twitter or Facebook for more. And don't forget to share your favourite miniature pictures and wargaming videos at www.pinsofwar.net.

  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/9360674@N04/sets/72157600510023664/ BrassScorpion

    Even those of us still in the miniatures hobby have made similar jokes about gamer guys not being able to get girls. And we all have met some gamers that are so over-the-top awkward that’s it seems plausible. The article forgot to mention the gamers that habitually smell bad, every gaming community seems to have a few of those.

    • http://pinsofwar.net/ Zweischneid

      True.

      I am not saying the stereotypes have no grounding in reality.

      But is, as Dr Stanely claims, the game/hobby to blame for the social/hygenic/whatever shortcomings of some gamers, or is it that the hobby attracts people leaning that way from the start?

      Tim Stanely himself recounts some rather unfortunate passages in his earlier life, when he “lost touch” with the world a bit as he delved into the hobby. He claims the hobby/Warhammer is to blame.

      I would argue that, in a parallel world without Warhammer, young Tim Stanely likely would’ve experienced similar problem, if perhaps in another (escapist) medium. No?

      • http://www.flickr.com/photos/9360674@N04/sets/72157600510023664/ BrassScorpion

        I wasn’t really expecting to go beyond joking about this and I’m not sure it’s a genuine “serious” discussion topic, but since you asked, yeah, if he let himself become something of a recluse due to Warhammer I’m sure he would have found something else to obsess over that would have caused him to have issues.

        One thing that worked well for me when I was young and single was that I had two groups of friends, one that consisted of gamers with whom I played D&D, etc. and another group with whom I just went out and had non-gamer fun. Probably not coincidentally, I met my wife while out one night with the latter group, not sitting inside playing D&D.

        • http://pinsofwar.net/ Zweischneid

          Yeah. It’s a rather odd article.

          The author wrote this in the comments on the Telegraph
          ———————

          It’s a joke – mostly parodying the tendency of politicians to try to ban things. I make it quite clear that I’m a geek and that I collected Warhammer, something I wouldn’t do if I was simply “bullying” fans. The post is stuffed full of hyperbole and bathos. I come out of it much worse than Warhammerers do.

          The irony is that writing this has got me in the mood for Warhammer again – after about six years of being clean. Tempted to start collected Tyranids…

          trs

          ———————

          Which really makes it more a failed (for me) attempt at humour.

          He’s (self-)deprecating people collecting miniatures as un-sociable to parody the political (populist?) activism to ban unpleasant things as means to garner votes (as opposed to .. out of personal bad experience)?

          Gives it less of a bit for hobbyists, but the political satire is .. dunno … confused.

  • http://veneficus-john-stevens.blogspot.com/ John Stevens

    this seems to be a tounge in cheek article rather then somthing sinister and serious. i think a mountain is being made out of a mole hill here.

    • http://pinsofwar.net/ Zweischneid

      Glad you consider my blog a mountain ;)

      Hey, I read the article, I did (!) acknowledge that claims to be satire, though the vibe I was getting from it were rather more scathing than humorous.

      But that may just be my reading of it.

      • http://veneficus-john-stevens.blogspot.com/ John Stevens

        Lol, what i was getting at is that it may be drawing a reasonably long bow to call him out for seriously wanting to ban warhammer/GW. Personally i love their IP but cant contemplate giving them my hard earned money due to their business practices/model. Any criticism towards GW is generally a positive thing as it helps transition people over to other games/companies that have less questionable business practices (though im also critical of PP’s move to use kickstarter), my interpretation of the article was that it was more of a cheap shot at the hobby and as you mentioned satire, i cant see anyone taking some of the comments he made seriously.

        • http://pinsofwar.net/ Zweischneid

          Well, I don’t believe he wants to really (!) ban Warhammer.

          As you said, it is satire. He’s taking a stab at David Cameron trying to ban pornography from the (British) Internet for very similar (albeit this time serious) reasons concerning the alleged damage to “social competence” online porn has on young boys.

          So this article “mocks” Cameron, saying he should ban Warhammer instead, as the hobby (satire!) impacts boys social behaviour even more negatively than excessive online-porn.

          All fine and dandy.

          Still, the “vibe” I picked up (perhaps wrongly) was one of underlying bitterness towards his own past Warhammer experiences, which the author seems to associate with rough patches in his life.

          Though, as said, I might have read that incorrectly (between the lines)